Current offer expires in
-- H
-- M
-- S
Up to 35% Off Sitewide
Shop Now

Strange Paranormal Cards

Filter

Safe Search on hides explicit content. Safe Search off shows all results, including explicit content.
Logo Card

Description: OG Strange Paranormal Logo

Tags: paranormal, paranormal investigator

Logo Card

by Strange Paranormal

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

X-Files - Scully Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Hope you like it.

Tags: 90s, retro, 90s tv, 1990s, whammy

X-Files - Scully Card

by OutlineArt

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Strange Things Department Paranormal Mystery Box Card
Main Tag:  

Description: A quirky bearded guy with a third eye holding a mystery crate.

Tags: curiosity, mystery, occult, oddity, psychedelic

Strange Things Department Paranormal Mystery Box Card

by REOSINS

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Mothman ate my entire ass at Denny’s Card
Main Tag:  

Description: This design is perfect for anyone who loves to embrace the weird and the unusual. Featuring an image of the infamous cryptid, the Mothman, and the phrase "Mothman ate my entire ass at Denny's," this design is both humorous and creepy. The message is clear: even cryptids need to eat, and apparently they have a taste for human butt. Whether you're a fan of horror, urban legends, or just enjoy a good laugh, this design is sure to turn heads and start conversations. So embrace the strange and celebrate the absurd with this unique and playful design!

Tags: cryptid, paranormal, humor, funny, weird

Mothman ate my entire ass at Denny’s Card

by Popstar Bowser

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Bigfoot Mothman Alien Vintage UFO Forest Art Card
Main Tag:  

Description: A vintage-style design featuring Bigfoot, Mothman, and an alien standing together in a mysterious forest, with UFOs flying above and a retro sun in the background. A perfect graphic for fans of cryptids, aliens, and strange sightings.

Tags: alien, bigfoot, cryptid monster, cryptozoology, fantasy creatures

Bigfoot Mothman Alien Vintage UFO Forest Art Card

by Tesszero

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

My Camera Has Never Once Found Him Funny Paranormal Mystery Horror Humor Card

Description: My camera has never once found him… and that’s starting to get suspicious. This creepy and mysterious design is perfect for paranormal enthusiasts, analog horror fans, cryptid hunters, conspiracy lovers, and anyone fascinated by unexplained sightings and figures that never seem to appear on camera.

Tags: analog horror aesthetic design, camera never captures him, creepy found footage mystery, creepy surveillance camera mystery, funny paranormal camera humor
Bordertown Strange Card

Description: Rep your favorite podcast with all our new updated design!

Tags: bordertown strange podcast, paranormal, paranormal podcast, strange, strange girls

Bordertown Strange Card

by Bordertown Paranormal

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Paranormal Laredo Card

Description: Podcaster and write

Tags: strange things with chris james, paranormal, ghosts, spirits, ufo

Paranormal Laredo Card

by Strange Things with Chris James

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Mothman ate my entire ass at Denny’s Card
Main Tag:  

Description: This design is perfect for anyone who loves to embrace the weird and the unusual. Featuring an image of the infamous cryptid, the Mothman, and the phrase "Mothman ate my entire ass at Denny's," this design is both humorous and creepy. The message is clear: even cryptids need to eat, and apparently they have a taste for human butt. Whether you're a fan of horror, urban legends, or just enjoy a good laugh, this design is sure to turn heads and start conversations. So embrace the strange and celebrate the absurd with this unique and playful design!

Tags: cryptid, paranormal, humor, funny, weird

Mothman ate my entire ass at Denny’s Card

by Popstar Bowser

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Bigfoot Alien Selfie Sasquatch Cryptid Mountain Paranormal Adventure Card

Description: Bigfoot leans into a hilarious wilderness selfie with a classic alien and other mysterious creatures beside a remote mountain lake. Detailed black and white engraving creates a nostalgic paranormal illustration combining Sasquatch folklore, alien encounters, cryptozoology, and outdoor adventure for Bigfoot fans and unexplained mystery enthusiasts.

Tags: alien, alien encounter, bigfoot, bigfoot believer, bigfoot humor
watching you eyes Card

Description: Feel like someone's watching? These eerie, unblinking eyes bring a mysterious, unsettling vibe to any collection of dark and creepy art.

Tags: all seeing eyes, creepy eyes, dark aesthetic, eerie eyes, gothic art

watching you eyes Card

by Xvex

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Spooky Fresno Nightcrawlers Poster Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Visit Fresno! 🗺️🌕 These creepy cryptids are just passing through in this vintage 1950s travel poster. Perfect for Halloween, paranormal investigators, and fans of spooky urban legends. Grab this retro eerie apparel and embrace the spooky season! 👽🌴🎃

Tags: alien vintage, creepy folklore, cryptid art, eerie, fresno nightcrawler

Spooky Fresno Nightcrawlers Poster Card

by Fictional Ink Society: Retro Old School & Geek Fan Art

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Investigation Team Social Club Vintage TV Mystery Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Show off your love for the unexplained with this retro television design. It is a great fit for fans of supernatural mysteries, cold cases, and late-night binge watching sessions.

Tags: amateur sleuth, cold case, conspiracy theory, cryptid hunter, cult classic

Investigation Team Social Club Vintage TV Mystery Card

by 0reooos ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Cryptozoology Mythical Creatures Field Guide Chart Card

Description: A detailed cryptozoology chart featuring a collection of legendary creatures from folklore and mysterious sightings. An intriguing gift for paranormal enthusiasts, mythology fans, oddity collectors, and lovers of unexplained beasts.

Tags: creature chart, fantas, folklore gift, folklore monsters, legendary beasts

Cryptozoology Mythical Creatures Field Guide Chart Card

by alien jaco

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

The Thing Card

Description: A creepy, ambiguous creature design that blends sci‑fi oddity with vintage horror mood. Simple, unsettling imagery inspired by cryptid and mystery monster themes.

Tags: alien creature, creepy monster, cryptid, dark creature, halloween creature

The Thing Card

by TegTeg

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Document the Weird — Field Research Division Card

Description: Not everything strange needs an explanation—but it deserves documentation. Document the Weird is the unofficial badge of photographers, back-road explorers, roadside investigators, cryptid hunters, and curious travelers who stop when everyone else keeps driving. Featuring a vintage 35mm camera, field notebook, compass, flashlight, mountain road, and one unexplained light on the horizon, this distressed expedition design follows a simple rule: Evidence Before Explanation. Inspired by vintage field-survey patches and 1970s outdoor graphics, it’s made for analog photographers, paranormal enthusiasts, hikers, urban explorers, and anyone drawn to forgotten roads, strange places, unexplained sightings, and stories hiding just beyond the map.

Tags: analog photography, back roads, cryptid, curious traveler, document the weird

Document the Weird — Field Research Division Card

by TheZenKozak

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Four Eyed Mystic Cat — Cosmic Guardian Card
Main Tag:  

Description: A strange four-eyed feline creature with a supernatural presence, blending cosmic mystery and dark fantasy aesthetics. A unique mystical animal design for lovers of weird creatures, occult art, and fantasy illustration.

Tags: alien cat, cosmic cat, creature design, dark fantasy, fantasy animal

Four Eyed Mystic Cat — Cosmic Guardian Card

by RavnFørge

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Paranormal Researcher Card

Description: I want to believe.

Tags: strange, alien abduction, conspiracy theories, outerspace, xfiles

Paranormal Researcher Card

by lilmousepunk

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

It's Fun to Believe (In Color!) Card

Description: Sport our OG design by Katy Raines (find more of her designs at https://www.facebook.com/krainesdesigns/) and let everyone know that it's FUN to believe!!

Tags: strange, paranormal, weird, weirdo, unusual

It's Fun to Believe (In Color!) Card

by Keep It Weird

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Official Roadside Anomaly Survey — If It’s Not on the Map, We’re Interested Card

Description: Some places deserve a closer look. The Official Roadside Anomaly Survey is for curious travelers who take the back roads, follow questionable signs, photograph forgotten places, and investigate anything the map forgot to mention. This distressed vintage field-research design combines an analog camera, compass, field notes, road map, mountain landscape, mysterious roadside imagery, and expedition gear into an old-school survey badge. Perfect for road-trip explorers, photographers, hikers, campers, roadside-attraction hunters, urban explorers, paranormal enthusiasts, and anyone who believes strange places make better stories. Curiosity requires indirect routes—and sometimes the most interesting destination is the one you weren’t looking for.

Tags: adventure, analog photography, back roads, field research, outdoor exploration
Stay Weird Kind People Alien Cat UFO Halloween Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Stay weird and stay kind. A strange little cosmic scene featuring a curious alien, a black cat caught in a UFO beam, pumpkins, mushrooms, stars, and retro autumn details. Made for alien believers, cat lovers, UFO watchers, paranormal fans, weird art collectors, spooky season enthusiasts, and kind people who have never had much interest in being normal.

Tags: alien cat, alien lover, black cat, cryptid aesthetic, cute alien

Stay Weird Kind People Alien Cat UFO Halloween Card

by MOTIFOLK

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Cat Alien UFO Abduction Card

Description: The truth is out there, and they want our pets! Add some sci-fi humor to your life with this hilarious line art design showing a confused kitty being beamed up into a flying saucer.

Tags: alien humor, alien spaceship, cat abduction, cat in space, extraterrestrial

Cat Alien UFO Abduction Card

by Bad Decisions

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Mothman Doom And Gloom Card

Description: Dark cryptid-style moth that leans into doom-and-gloom horror. Eerie nocturnal mood with gothic details.

Tags: creepy insect, cryptid, dark drawing, doom and gloom, eerie

Mothman Doom And Gloom Card

by SweetAdriaan

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Why dost thou hide thyself in clouds?, William Blake Shirt, Poetry T-shirt, Eye of God, Poem, Fantasy Book Lover T-shirt Tshirt Tee Tees Meme Vintage Art Card

Description: Why dost thou hide thyself in clouds?, William Blake Shirt, Poetry T-shirt, Eye of God, Poem, Fantasy Book Lover T-shirt Tshirt Tee Tees Meme Vintage Art

Tags: aesthetic, best friend, dark art, dark humor, funny gift
Haunted Radio, Vintage Creepy Broadcast, Paranormal Frequency Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Something is broadcasting after midnight. A creepy vintage radio tuned to a frequency that probably shouldn't exist. This eerie retro design combines old-school radio nostalgia with haunted broadcasts, mysterious signals, and late-night horror vibes. Perfect for horror fans, lovers of vintage electronics, paranormal enthusiasts, and anyone who enjoys things that feel slightly wrong.

Tags: creepy broadcast, haunted broadcast, midnight radio, paranormal signal, strange frequency

Haunted Radio, Vintage Creepy Broadcast, Paranormal Frequency Card

by BlueinkSupply

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Mothman ate my entire a*s at Denny’s Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Mothman ate my entire a*s at Denny’s

Tags: conspiracy theories, creepy, cryptid, cryptid sightings, dennys

Mothman ate my entire a*s at Denny’s Card

by Novnsa Store

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

The Truth Is Weird Exploring the Unexplained Card

Description: The truth is weird, and that’s what makes it fun. This badge-style design is for curious minds who love mysteries, odd facts, and chasing down the unexplained. A fun gift for conspiracy theory jokers, trivia fans, explorers, and anyone who never takes the obvious answer.

Tags: badge design, curiosity, curious mind, explorer, funny saying

The Truth Is Weird Exploring the Unexplained Card

by ShatteredZ

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Vintage Mothman Graphic Tshirt, Retro 90s Tee, Creepy, Cryptid Shirt, Monster, Dark Art, Grimdark, Witch, Halloween, Gift For Him, Y2k Card

Description: Vintage Mothman Graphic Tshirt, Retro 90s Tee, Creepy, Cryptid Shirt, Monster, Dark Art, Grimdark, Witch, Halloween, Gift For Him, Y2k

Tags: cryptid, cryptozoology, dark art, funny gift, meme
Bigfoot Alien Heart Hands Cryptid Extraterrestrial Paranormal Love Card

Description: Bigfoot Alien Heart Hands Design. Features Sasquatch And Extraterrestrial Alien Creating A Heart Symbol. Ideal For Paranormal Lovers, Cryptid Fans, UFO Believers, And Mysterious Creature Enthusiasts.

Tags: alien, couple, cryptid, extraterrestrial, friendship
bigfoot alien conspiracy Card

Description: bigfoot alien conspiracy

Tags: alien, alien abduction, alien encounter, aliens, bigfoot

bigfoot alien conspiracy Card

by Xvex

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Javelina's Java Card

Description: Now at Javelina's - Happy Harvest Spice! It's good, yeah? So do your part and SPREAD THE SPICE!!! Just because you're part of a hive mind doesn't mean you shouldn't have delicious coffee.

Tags: horror, sci fi, anthology, coffee, podcast

Javelina's Java Card

by UncannyCountyStore

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Stay Spooky And Weird Halloween Ghost Spooky Weirdo Goth Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Embrace the Halloween season with this Spooky Ghost design. Perfect for Goth, Weirdo, and Unique individuals who love the supernatural. Stay Spooky And Weird.

Tags: autumn, creepy, fall, ghost, goth

Stay Spooky And Weird Halloween Ghost Spooky Weirdo Goth Card

by xmillionpunks

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Welcome Committee Hospitality Paimon Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Celebrate the darker side of hospitality with this whimsical suburban scene. Featuring children greeting a mysterious shadow entity with balloons and a banner, this retro comic-style aesthetic blends spooky horror vibes with ironic neighborhood charm. Perfect for fans of occult humor and quirky, strange, and creepy dark comedies.

Tags: creepy, dark humor, eerie, gothic, horror

Welcome Committee Hospitality Paimon Card

by Eliteskulsstudio

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Retro Mothman Eating Soup Cryptid 90s Shirt. Funny Cryptid Vintage T-Shirt, Fantasy Book Lover T-shirt Tshirt Tee Tees Meme Moth Man Card

Description: Retro Mothman Eating Soup Cryptid 90s Shirt. Funny Cryptid Vintage T-Shirt, Fantasy Book Lover T-shirt Tshirt Tee Tees Meme Moth Man

Tags: cryptid, cryptid hunter, cryptozoology, dark art, funny cryptid
I Want to Believe Fresno Nightcrawler Cryptid Card

Description: I Want to Believe artwork featuring mysterious white Fresno Nightcrawlers beneath a huge red moon in a dark forest. An eerie paranormal design inspired by cryptid sightings, unexplained creatures and late-night encounters with the unknown.

Tags: cryptid, cryptid lover, cryptozoology, fresno nightcrawlers, i want to believe

I Want to Believe Fresno Nightcrawler Cryptid Card

by Pandaburba Illustrations

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

STRANGE THINGS ARE HAPPENING. Card

Description: STRANGE THINGS ARE HAPPENING.

Tags: creepy aesthetic, eerie saying, mystery quote, paranormal humor, spooky vibes

STRANGE THINGS ARE HAPPENING. Card

by Gnobles

$5.00 $6.00

for
--
:
--
:
--

Similar Designs

Cart Preview (0)

Adult Apparel

Kids Apparel

Accessories