Current offer expires in
-- H
-- M
-- S
Up to 40% Off Sitewide
Shop Now

Supernatural Horror Cards

Filter

Safe Search on hides explicit content. Safe Search off shows all results, including explicit content.
Black Christmas 1974 Vintage Card

Description: Black Christmas (originally titled Silent Night, Evil Night in the United States and retitled Stranger in the House on television screenings) is a 1974 Canadian slasher film produced and directed by Bob Clark, and written by Roy Moore. It stars Olivia Hussey, Keir Dullea, Margot Kidder, and John Saxon. The story follows a group of sorority sisters who receive threatening phone calls and are eventually stalked and murdered by a killer during the Christmas season.

Tags: 70s horror, black, black christmas, black santa, blood

Black Christmas 1974 Vintage Card

by YourDailyTees

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Love Supernatural 2 Card

Description: 100% adorableness for total fan awesomeness!

Tags: bobby, cartoon, castiel, crowley, cute

Love Supernatural 2 Card

by KYi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Card

Description: Carry on, wayward hunter! This design is perfect for fans of classic supernatural lore, road-tripping adventures, and all things eerie. Featuring a vintage-inspired aesthetic with symbols of protection, it’s a must-have for those who love demon-hunting, mysterious creatures, and legendary brotherly bonds. The Winchester brothers Sam and Dean fans would love this. The Family Business, saving people hunting things.

Tags: carry on my wayward son, castiel, dean winchester, demon hunters, horror

Supernatural Card

by Scorpi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Love Supernatural 1 Card

Description: 100% adorableness for total fan awesomeness!

Tags: cartoon, castiel, crowley, cute, dean winchester

Love Supernatural 1 Card

by KYi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Love Moose & Squirrel - Supernatural Card

Description: 100% adorableness for total fan awesomeness!

Tags: castiel, crowley, cute, dean winchester, fandom

Love Moose & Squirrel - Supernatural Card

by KYi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Family Business T-Shirt Card

Description: Saving People....Hunting Things...The Family Business. It's just me you, you and me. Brothers Forever. Supernatural, winchester brothers, winchester bros, brothers, dean winchester, sam winchester, family business, hunting things, demons, devil trap, horror, castiel, gabriel, lucifer, jack, metatron, Prophet, Angels, Demons, God, Supernatural Fans,

Tags: sam and dean, horror, winchester, supernatural design, supernatural fan art

Supernatural Family Business T-Shirt Card

by Seven Twenty Three

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Alien Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Science-fiction horror film.

Tags: scary, sci fi, horror, science fiction, monster

Alien Card

by TravisKnight

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Trauma | Retro Supernatural Horror Movie Poster Card

Description: An original vintage-inspired supernatural horror movie poster featuring a haunted Victorian mansion, mysterious shadow creatures and a fearless heroine fighting to survive. Inspired by classic late 1970s and early 1980s horror cinema, this fictional cult movie design combines grindhouse aesthetics, VHS-era nostalgia and bold hand-painted pulp artwork.

Tags: 80s horror, cult cinema, exploitation art, grindhouse, haunted house

Trauma | Retro Supernatural Horror Movie Poster Card

by Obstinator

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Love Supernatural Card

Description: 100% adorableness for total fan awesomeness!

Tags: bobby, castiel, cosplay, cute, dean winchester

Love Supernatural Card

by KYi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

The Lost Boys Card

Description: Inspired by The Lost Boys your favorite supernatural black comedy horror film

Tags: back catalog, black comedy, edgar frog, horror, hunter

The Lost Boys Card

by theusher

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

The Exorcist Card

Description: The Exorcist

Tags: 1970s, creepy, dark, demon, evil

The Exorcist Card

by Dmitry

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Love Sam, Dean & Castiel - Supernatural Card

Description: KYi (kawaii) is 100% adorableness

Tags: funny, cute, fiction, kawaii, tv

Love Sam, Dean & Castiel - Supernatural Card

by KYi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Mothman Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Mothman T-shirt

Tags: mothman art, creature, cryptid, supernatural, spooky

Mothman Card

by Tesszero

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Love Supernatural Card

Description: 100% adorableness for total fan awesomeness!

Tags: castiel, cosplay, cute, dean winchester, fangirl

Love Supernatural Card

by KYi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Scooby Natural Supernatural Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Scooby Natural Supernatural

Tags: animated crossover, cult tv episode, dean winchester, horror comedy, sam winchester

Scooby Natural Supernatural Card

by Retro Valley

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Love Castiel - Supernatural Card

Description: 100% adorableness for total fan awesomeness!

Tags: cas, castiel, fandom, funny, scifi

Love Castiel - Supernatural Card

by KYi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Impala Card

Description: The Chevrolet Impala parked in front of a Haunted house

Tags: haunted house, impala, halloween, supernatural fan art, horror

Supernatural Impala Card

by Alien Dropship

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

A Nightmare on Elm Street Card

Description: Nancy Thompson

Tags: 1980s, 90s, dreams, film, freddy krueger

A Nightmare on Elm Street Card

by Dmitry

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

A Supernatural Christmas Card
Main Tag:  

Description: When they’re not saving people, they’re Saving Christmas, and you can too with this awesome SPN family ugly sweater, or the perfect gift for your special Moose or Squirrel.

Tags: sweater pattern, horror, supernatural, christmas, ugly sweater

A Supernatural Christmas Card

by HappyLlama

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Love Sam & Dean - Supernatural Card

Description: 100% adorableness for total fan awesomeness!

Tags: castiel, cute, dean winchester, fanart, fangirl

Love Sam & Dean - Supernatural Card

by KYi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

FBI Wanted Poster T Shirt Card

Description: FBI Wanted Poster T Shirt

Tags: sam winchester, dean winchester, crowley, lucifer, the winchesters

FBI Wanted Poster T Shirt Card

by Zen Threads

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Love Bobby - Supernatural Card

Description: 100% adorableness for total fan awesomeness!

Tags: bobby, castiel, dean, funny, geek

Love Bobby - Supernatural Card

by KYi

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Action Movie Sinners 2025 Card
Main Tag:  

Description: Action Movie Sinners 2025

Tags: cinema, horror action, movie 2025, remmick, smoke

Action Movie Sinners 2025 Card

by BIttuvin

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Demons I get, people are crazy Card

Description: A design dedicated to the TV show Supernatural

Tags: dean winchester, demon, halloween, horror, pentagram

Demons I get, people are crazy Card

by Alien Dropship

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

The King in Yellow - xanthous Card

Description: A mysterious and malevolent supernatural and gothic entity known as the King in Yellow...

Tags: carcosa, cosmic horror, cthulhu mythos, gothic, great old ones

The King in Yellow - xanthous Card

by HtCRU

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Mothman Card
Main Tag:  

Description: MOTHMAN

Tags: creature, cryptid, cryptids, cryptozoology, halloween

Mothman Card

by huckblade

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Card

Description: Long-running series following brothers hunting monsters and demons.

Tags: classic show, horror drama, monster hunters, show art, sitcom classic

Supernatural Card

by Void UP

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Card

Description: Long-running series following brothers hunting monsters and demons.

Tags: classic show, horror drama, monster hunters, show art, sitcom classic

Supernatural Card

by Ando Sugiha

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Card

Description: Long-running series following brothers hunting monsters and demons.

Tags: classic show, horror drama, monster hunters, show art, sitcom classic

Supernatural Card

by Ando Sugiha

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Lucifer Card

Description: Supernatural fans and lovers of Lucifer. Here you go. A shirt that puts the big bad boy in his cage.

Tags: scary, horror, demon, devils, supernatural symbols

Supernatural Lucifer Card

by damienmayfield.com

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Devil's trap Card

Description: I'm a huge fan of Supernatural series. Do you remember what was the best weapon against demons? Yes, it was a devil's trap. Sam and Dean Winchester were using it a lot. Now I'm presenting it as my fan art.

Tags: devil, magic, devils trap, black, sign

Devil's trap Card

by Anilia

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

supernatural Card

Description: American television series

Tags: demon, devil, evil, fantasy, halloween

supernatural Card

by Suzukiharuka

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Card

Description: Supernatural film design

Tags: actor, actress, celebrity, cinema, drama

Supernatural Card

by Whimsy Threads Studio

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Movie Face Collage Horror Card

Description: Supernatural Movie Face Collage Horror

Tags: cinema, dark art, ghosts, gore, horror

Supernatural Movie Face Collage Horror Card

by Glow $pher£

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

supernatural Card

Description: supernatural

Tags: autumn, fall, fantasy, halloween, horror

supernatural Card

by oyeplot

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Supernatural Cat Horror Portrait Card

Description: Supernatural Cat Horror Portrait

Tags: dark fantasy, demon, devil, horror, occult

Supernatural Cat Horror Portrait Card

by MamuangAuto

$5.00 $6.00

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Similar Designs

Cart Preview (0)

Adult Apparel

Kids Apparel

Accessories