FREE US Shipping for Orders  $80+

Cart Preview (0)

You're $80.00 Away from FREE US Shipping!
$0
$80

Adult Apparel

Kids Apparel

Home Goods

Ayaotd Pins and Buttons

Search Results
Get 25% OFF when you buy 4+ pins!
*Cannot be combined with additional sales/discounts.
Are You Afraid of the Dark - Station 109.1 FM - Radio for the Dimensionally Challenged Pin
Are You Afraid of the Dark Pin

Are You Afraid of the Dark Pin

by huckblade
$3.00
The Tale of Laughing in the Dark Pin
Sardo's Magic Mansion Pin

Sardo's Magic Mansion Pin

by huckblade
$3.00
Midnight Society Alumni 1990 Pin

Midnight Society Alumni 1990 Pin

by spookyruthy
$3.00
Zeebo - Are You Afraid of the Dark? Pin
Ghastly Grinner - Are You Afraid of the Dark Pin
Are You Afraid of the Dark - The Vacant Lot - The Blasters Pin
Totally Not A Zeeb - Are You Afraid of the Dark - Nickelodeon Pin
The Midnight Society Pin

The Midnight Society Pin

by Nazonian
$3.00
The Tale of Dead Man's Float Pin

The Tale of Dead Man's Float Pin

by spookyruthy
$3.00
Sardo's Magic Mansion (Variant) Pin
The Midnight Society Pin

The Midnight Society Pin

by huckblade
$3.00
Are You Afraid of the Dark? | Toy Factory Pin
The Midnight Society (Variant) Pin
Are You Afraid of the Dark - Bookish Babysitter Belinda Pin
Are You Afraid of the Dark? - It's The Most Fun in the Park Pin

Pin FAQ

Where can I find other ayaotd designs? Expand or collapse section.
In addition to ayaotd designs, you can explore the marketplace for are you afraid of the dark, 90s, and nickelodeon designs sold by independent artists.
What material is this item made of? Expand or collapse section.

Classic pin-back button covered with scratch and UV-resistant mylar. Printed in the U.S.A.

What USA ship methods are available? Expand or collapse section.

UPS MI Domestic (6-8 Business Days)

FedEx 2-Day (4-6 Business Days)

Estimates include printing and processing time.More Shipping Info

What is the Return/Exchange policy? Expand or collapse section.

We want you to love your order! If for any reason you don't, let us know and we’ll make things right.Learn More

Close Click to close this dialog.