Prices increase in
-- H
-- M
-- S
Up to 40% Off Sitewide
Shop Now

Creepy Eye Pins and Buttons

Filter

Safe Search on hides explicit content. Safe Search off shows all results, including explicit content.
Melting Eye With Weird Eyelashes Psychedelic Art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Weird eye digital illustration depicting a creepy red eye with eyelashes which have their own eyelashes and are ending in flowers red and grey flowers. This creepy eye design is for you if you like bizarre, dark, strange stuff.

Tags: art, bizarre, creepy, eye, eye art

Melting Eye With Weird Eyelashes Psychedelic Art Pin

by Boriana

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Psychedelic Hypnotic Art Creepy Double Pink Eye Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Hypnotic creepy pink eye design with a tattoo style trippy vector illustration of a weird eye with strange striped and dotted eyelashes. One of the eyelashes is deformed into another pink eye. This cool dark design is great for Halloween, as well as people who love macabre, gothic, surreal style of art.

Tags: weird, eye, psychedelic, cool, hypnotic

Psychedelic Hypnotic Art Creepy Double Pink Eye Pin

by Boriana

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Horror eye tentacle monster creepy weird gothic art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Horror art with creepy broken eye and a tentacle monster coming out of the fractured iris against intense orange background. Great for a person who likes gothic art and weird stuff.

Tags: eyeball, goth, eye, creepy, monster

Horror eye tentacle monster creepy weird gothic art Pin

by Boriana

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Pushead Bird's Eye – Webpunk Skeleton Creature Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This highly detailed illustration channels a Pushead-inspired aesthetic with its intricate linework, surreal anatomy, and bold, uneasy atmosphere. The artwork features a skeletal bird-like creature entangled in a neon web, complete with exaggerated claws, a distorted skull, and a large, vividly rendered eyeball that creates a dramatic focal point. The mix of punk horror, surreal fantasy, and gritty graphic style gives the design a striking underground-art energy. Perfect for fans of skate art, punk graphics, creepy creature design, and bold alternative visuals, this piece delivers a raw, chaotic, and unforgettable artistic statement.

Tags: alt, art graphic, creature, creepy, eyeball

Pushead Bird's Eye – Webpunk Skeleton Creature Pin

by Alcazarorca

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

The Creeping Eye Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: It’s going to creep over to where you’re at AND Look at you! The Creeping Eye! Prepare to feel Awkward. A parody of the horror classic The Crawling Eye.

Tags: movies, classic, horror, bad, cult

The Creeping Eye Pin

by JARHUMOR

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Creepy Smile Cat Meme Funny Cursed Eye Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A hilarious uncanny design featuring a smiling cat with weirdly unsettling and cursed meme vibes.

Tags: black cat, cat, cat lover, cats, catshirt

Creepy Smile Cat Meme Funny Cursed Eye Pin

by MoonCrank

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Path to the Eye Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: An Automatic Drawing that ended up being a creepy gorge going towards a giant eye.

Tags: simple design, lineart, black and white, gorge, flames

Path to the Eye Pin

by Broken Grin

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Scary Cartoon Monster with Glowing Eye in Dark Forest Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This design features a creepy cartoon monster with a glowing yellow eye lurking among dark, twisted trees in a spooky forest setting. Perfect for fans of horror and eerie artwork looking for a chilling and atmospheric design.

Tags: dark forest, eerie woods, glowing eye, halloween horror, haunted forest

Scary Cartoon Monster with Glowing Eye in Dark Forest Pin

by CLBCreativesMerch

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Make It Creepy Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Make It Creepy saying with eyeballs. With grunge halftone distress

Tags: creature, distressed, eye, eyeballs, eyes

Make It Creepy Pin

by Awake Productions

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Creepy Eye Keyhole Dark Horror Halloween Art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A disturbing bleeding eye staring through a weathered keyhole in a gritty black and white psychological horror design.

Tags: creepy, eyes, halloween for girls, halloween for men, halloween for women

Creepy Eye Keyhole Dark Horror Halloween Art Pin

by Aru Studio

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Seek & Find (Day Variant) Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Seek and ye shall find.

Tags: blackandwhite, creepy, esoteric, eyes, faith

Seek & Find (Day Variant) Pin

by WYRDICA

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Eye See You Creepy Eyeball Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Eye See You artwork featuring a monstrous floating eyeball with trailing red veins and a tiny hand mirror. A surreal horror design for fans of weird monsters, anatomical horror and creepy visual puns.

Tags: anatomical horror, creepy eye, creepy eyeball, eye horror, eyeball

Eye See You Creepy Eyeball Pin

by Pandaburba Illustrations

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Creepy Flying Eye Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: halloween style illustration design simple drawing bat wing with big eye

Tags: creature, creepy, eye, eyeball, halloween

Creepy Flying Eye Pin

by crissbahari

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Eye Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A weird hand drawn eyeball to stare at everyone for you.

Tags: creepy, doodle, drawing, eyeball, eyes

Eye Pin

by Coconut_TEES

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Blushing Eye Monster with Long Lashes Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A purple one-eyed monster with long lashes, a toothy grin and little eyes on every tentacle. For DnD players and fans of creepy cute monsters.

Tags: blushing, creepy cute, cyclops, eyelashes, fantasy creature

Blushing Eye Monster with Long Lashes Pin

by Djangle Studio

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Eye with Wings Motif Monochrome Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A monochrome composition featuring a central, detailed eye. Surrounding the central eye are four clusters of smaller eyes, each adorned with feathered wings. The style is line-based with strong contrast against a black background.

Tags: abstract, black and white, creepy, detailed, eyeeyes

Eye with Wings Motif Monochrome Pin

by jn.anime

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Be Kind Not A Monster Werewolf Holding Heart Eye Pumpkin Pin

Description: A ferocious werewolf gently holds an orange jack-o'-lantern carved with sweet heart-shaped eyes above motivational anti-bullying text. Combining horror aesthetics with an uplifting message, it makes a memorable statement for teachers and advocates.

Tags: anti bullying awareness teacher, classic werewolf monster quote, creepy sweet monster message, cute heart eye pumpkin, halloween anti bullying campaign

Be Kind Not A Monster Werewolf Holding Heart Eye Pumpkin Pin

by ArtMichalShop

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Eye Scream Cones Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Four creepy ice cream cones arranged in a circle, each featuring a single large staring eyeball.

Tags: bizarre, delicious, dessert, eye, eyeball

Eye Scream Cones Pin

by saara artworld

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Claw Peering Eye Spooky Horror Game Art Pin

Description: Claw Peering Eye Spooky Horror Game Art

Tags: bloody claws, creepy, dark fantasy, go, gore art

Claw Peering Eye Spooky Horror Game Art Pin

by Luna Bunny Studio

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Spider Eye Lamb Dark Weirdcore Aesthetic T-Shirt Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Embrace eerie surreal horror with this dark spider eye lamb design. Perfect for fans of weirdcore, dark academia, macabre art, and unsettling aesthetic imagery.

Tags: creepy aesthetic, dark academia, dark art, dark poetry, dreamcore

Spider Eye Lamb Dark Weirdcore Aesthetic T-Shirt Pin

by Fristal-afk4

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Sick Sad World Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Sick Sad World

Tags: 90s, angst, creepy, eye, eyes

Sick Sad World Pin

by Maakoda

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Cosmic Eyeball Crystal Horror Art | Surreal Creepy Eye Design Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A surreal cosmic eyeball floating above glowing crystal formations with toxic slime dripping into the darkness. This creepy horror-inspired design blends psychedelic vibes, fantasy aesthetics, and spooky surrealism into one bold artwork perfect for Halloween lovers, alternative fashion fans, gamers, and dark art collectors. Ideal for t-shirts, stickers, hoodies, and gifts for anyone obsessed with weirdcore, occult visuals, and eye-catching creepy designs.

Tags: creepy cute horror, cyberpunk art, halloween aesthetic, retro halloween, spooky
Intense Spiral Eye Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Intense Spiral Eye

Tags: black and white, creepy art, gaze, graphic illustration, horror manga

Intense Spiral Eye Pin

by Exoskeleton Anis

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Eye people Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Eye

Tags: graphic, eyes, creepy

Eye people Pin

by ido_raz

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

All Monsters Are Human Creepy Quote Dark Aesthetic Design Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Embrace the dark side with this All Monsters Are Human design. Featuring a unique eye illustration and bold typography, this creepy quote is perfect for fans of gothic art, psychological horror, and edgy, thought-provoking aesthetics.

Tags: alternative style, creepy art, dark aesthetic, dark humor, edgy quote

All Monsters Are Human Creepy Quote Dark Aesthetic Design Pin

by oussnaknak

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Eye monster Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Art and photo by misschloemay

Tags: abstract, artistic, artsy, colorful, creepy

Eye monster Pin

by Misschloemay

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Creepy Weird Eye Garlands Surreal Art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Creepy eye design with a weird pattern created from a cool digital ink illustration of staring blue and green eyes with long eyelashes arranged like garlands.

Tags: abstract, cool, crazy, creepy, eyes

Creepy Weird Eye Garlands Surreal Art Pin

by Boriana

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Fractured Lava Eye Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Cool eye art featuring a digital illustration of an eye with long eyelashes ending with flowers and fractured yellow orange iris.

Tags: creepy, bizarre, surreal, surrealism, eye

Fractured Lava Eye Pin

by Boriana

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Halloween On The Brain Red Skull Vampire Grim Reaper Eyeballs Pin

Description: A crimson skull opens at the top to expose a human brain surrounded by a vampire, grim reaper, black cat, and reaching zombie hands with eyeballs. Designed with halftone shading and rich red tones, it appeals to hardcore horror fans.

Tags: black cat spell books, classic dracula horror monsters, creepy halloween brain overflow, full moon flying bats, grim reaper scythe scarecrow

Halloween On The Brain Red Skull Vampire Grim Reaper Eyeballs Pin

by ArtMichalShop

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Voodoo Witch: Midnight Broomstick Flight Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Soar into the dark fantasy realm with this enchanting ragdoll voodoo witch riding her magical broomstick. Featuring stitched button eyes, a patched burlap witch hat, and glowing emerald potion smoke, this creepy-cute artwork merges spooky gothic flair with whimsical fairytale detail. The fluid, sweeping composition and vibrant green glow create a striking visual against dark apparel. Perfect for gothic fashion lovers, Halloween aesthetic fans, and dark fantasy art collectors. Engineered for high-impact print-on-demand graphic tees, hoodies, and streetwear accessories.

Tags: broomstick witch design, button eye doll, creepy cute anime, dark fantasy apparel, fairytale witch

Voodoo Witch: Midnight Broomstick Flight Pin

by cashfish

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Run Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: He’s at the door

Tags: creep, eye, eyes, freak, freaky

Run Pin

by Loveless Visions

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Creepy Stitched Black Cat Illustration Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A creepy patchwork black cat plush with a glowing red eye, holding a needle and thread, perfect for gothic and horror-inspired apparel and accessories.

Tags: creepy cute design, stitched toy art, patchwork character, gothic cat illustration, horror plush sty

Creepy Stitched Black Cat Illustration Pin

by Irina_graphicart

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Mysterious Woman With Red Eye Shushing Silence — Dark Horror Portrait Illustration Creepy Girl Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A stylized horror portrait of a pale woman with a glowing red eye pressing a finger to her lips in a shushing gesture, evoking silence, mystery, and unsettling, eerie atmosphere.

Tags: beautiful woman, dark art, emo, goth, gothic
Sick Sad World Melting Eye Surreal Graphic Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A surreal circular graphic featuring the words “SICK SAD WORLD” in dripping cream lettering around a watchful central eye. Green and blue concentric rings create a hypnotic, moody backdrop with a dark alternative feel. A fitting choice for fans of weirdcore, gloomy humor, psychedelic visuals, and unconventional artwork, whether worn casually or given as an edgy gift.

Tags: alternative style, blue rings, creepy aesthetic, dark humor, edgy gift

Sick Sad World Melting Eye Surreal Graphic Pin

by Mountage

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

They're Watching You They Aren't Happy – Creepy Eye Pin

Description: A bold hand-lettered typography design featuring the eerie quote "They're Watching You. They Aren't Happy." with a single watchful eye seamlessly integrated into the word YOU for a subtle yet striking visual effect. Designed in crisp white on a solid black background with thick brush lettering, this minimalist graphic delivers a mysterious, unsettling vibe while remaining clean and modern. Perfect for fans of creepy aesthetics, dark humor, horror-inspired art, conspiracy themes, and bold statement typography. A unique conversation-starting design for those who enjoy mysterious and eye-catching apparel.Title

Tags: dark humor, funny, funny gift, funny sayings, funnytee

They're Watching You They Aren't Happy – Creepy Eye Pin

by Mindsets Valleys

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Gothic Horror Bloodshot Psycho Eye Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Dark and aggressive gothic style psycho eye with bloodshot details and heavy ink splatters. Ultimate graphic for punk, heavy metal, and horror art fans.

Tags: aggressive tattoo, bloodshot eye, comic horror, creepy eyeball, dark fantasy

Gothic Horror Bloodshot Psycho Eye Pin

by Masoki

$2.75 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Similar Designs

Cart Preview (0)

Adult Apparel

Kids Apparel

Home Goods