Current offer expires in
-- H
-- M
-- S
Up to 40% Off Sitewide
Shop Now

Gothic Mystery Pins and Buttons

Filter

Safe Search on hides explicit content. Safe Search off shows all results, including explicit content.
Mystery Staircase Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Mystery Staircase

Tags: mystery theme, fantasy, magic, occult, gothic

Mystery Staircase Pin

by barmalisiRTB

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

gothic mystery Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A pale gothic woman with red eyes appears above a haunted castle, bats, shadowy crowds, and a crimson forest.

Tags: dark fantasy, flying bats, haunted castle, red eyes, sinister woman

gothic mystery Pin

by Fleming Happy

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Clair Obscur – Expedition 33 Petal Fade Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: An elegant and mysterious number design inspired by abstract journeys and fading petals. “33” is stylized with a distressed, cinematic style that blends beautifully into a cascade of falling petals—perfect for fans of atmospheric storytelling, numerology, or minimal surreal art. A tribute to mystery, beauty, and the unknown.

Tags: 33, abstract design, bloom, cinematic style, dark

Clair Obscur – Expedition 33 Petal Fade Pin

by Frogtitude

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Mystery's Child Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: White eyes pierce the gloom, Dead trees stand, a silent host, Gorey's child watches.

Tags: edward gorey style, goth, goth girl, gothic aesthetic, gothic art

Mystery's Child Pin

by C. Autumn Trapp

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Keyhole Gothic Tower Mystery Figure Roses Pin

Description: Keyhole Gothic Tower Mystery Figure Roses

Tags: adventure, dark art, enigmatic, fantasy, gothic

Keyhole Gothic Tower Mystery Figure Roses Pin

by shooplokaj

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Mystery Man Gothic Rock Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Mystery Man Gothic Rock.

Tags: band, gothic rock, hardcore punk, metalcore, metallic hardcore

Mystery Man Gothic Rock Pin

by Craftd.Lab

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Halloween Mystery Showcase Y2k Post Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Vibrant purple and blue mystery design featuring anime style characters with hats, stars, and bold lettering for modern pop fans.

Tags: anime illustration, gothic pop, kpop hunters, mysterious character, purple aesthetic

Halloween Mystery Showcase Y2k Post Pin

by MARKIBAROQ

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Victorian Mystery Salem Massachusetts Last Visitor Graphic Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Features a striking vintage woodcut illustration of a top-hatted gentleman walking through a 1830s Salem Massachusetts hall. Ideal for fans of victorian mystery, dark academia fashion, and gothic historical archives. A great gift for lovers of 19th-century history and mystery stories.

Tags: 19th century, dark academia, gothic history, historic archive, historical fiction

Victorian Mystery Salem Massachusetts Last Visitor Graphic Pin

by PopArtyParty

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Mystery Market Cat Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween artwork featuring a black cat as the dominant focal point for mystery shop. Main text: MYSTERY MARKET CAT. Secondary text: SOMETHING SPOOKY INSIDE. Made for black cat lovers and Halloween fans, with a distinct layered foreground-midground-background scene with the cat larger than every prop.

Tags: autumn market, black, black cat, black cat halloween, cat lover

Mystery Market Cat Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween Pin

by Symbolic Studio

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Sherlock Holmes The Speckled Band Gothic Snake Mystery Art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This dark and atmospheric woodcut style artwork illustrates Arthur Conan Doyle's spine-chilling Sherlock Holmes tale, The Speckled Band. The gritty design showcases a menacing venomous snake coiled around a hanging rope above a glowing vintage lantern. This eerie gothic illustration is tailor-made for book lovers, horror fans, and classic literature readers.

Tags: band, book, bookish, conan doyle, dark academia

Sherlock Holmes The Speckled Band Gothic Snake Mystery Art Pin

by Fenay Designs

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Sherlock Holmes Baskerville Moor Gothic Hound Mystery Art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Feel the eerie suspense of Arthur Conan Doyle's most famous masterpiece with this striking Baskerville Moor design. The graphic artwork features a vibrant green geometric hound head with glowing yellow eyes looming over a misty moor and a lonely estate under a full moon. This dark gothic aesthetic is a spectacular choice for bookworms, classic literature readers, and mystery fiction fans.

Tags: baskerville, book, book lover, bookish, bookworm

Sherlock Holmes Baskerville Moor Gothic Hound Mystery Art Pin

by Fenay Designs

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Skeleton Cloak Mystery Concept Pin

Description: Skeleton Cloak Mystery Concept

Tags: burzum, dark art, death, gothic, grim reaper

Skeleton Cloak Mystery Concept Pin

by Bloom Doodle Mood

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Midnight Ritual Gothic Cathedral Candle Design Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Embrace the darkness with this gothic cathedral design. Featuring a mysterious candle, a crescent moon, and symbolic elements, it's perfect for those who love dark aesthetics and occult themes.

Tags: arcane, atmospheric, candle, cathedral, dark

Midnight Ritual Gothic Cathedral Candle Design Pin

by Artpxdar

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Castlevania Inspired Dark Gothic Vampire Design Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Explore a dark gothic vampire design inspired by classic horror and fantasy themes, perfect for fans of mysterious and eerie aesthetics.

Tags: castle, creepy, dark art, dark fantasy, fantasy

Castlevania Inspired Dark Gothic Vampire Design Pin

by SKRIBINK

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Crimson Peak Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A house as old as this one becomes, in time, a living thing.

Tags: lucille sharpe, thomas sharpe, dr alan mcmichael, blood, back catalog

Crimson Peak Pin

by FelixT

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Autumn Bazaar Cat Retro Halloween Poster Halloween Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Retro Halloween Poster Halloween artwork featuring a black cat as the dominant focal point for autumn bazaar. Main text: AUTUMN BAZAAR CAT. Secondary text: MARKET NIGHTS & MOONLIGHT. Made for black cat lovers and Halloween fans, with a distinct layered foreground-midground-background scene with the cat larger than every prop.

Tags: autumn market, black cat halloween, cat lover, dark aesthetic, gothic cat

Autumn Bazaar Cat Retro Halloween Poster Halloween Pin

by Symbolic Studio

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

House Of Nightmares Pin

Description: Enter if you dare, this haunted house is sure to terrify you this Halloween!

Tags: backcountry appalachia southern gothic, creepy scary spooky horror, dark nightmare haunting goth, fall autumn september october 31st, forgotten dilapidated disrepair

House Of Nightmares Pin

by Jan Grackle

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Gothic Clover Raccoon Skulls & Roses Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This edgy gothic raccoon design features a lucky four-leaf clover surrounded by skulls and thorny roses. Perfect for fans of dark tattoo art, paranormal vibes, and unique wildlife illustrations with a spooky twist.

Tags: animal, clover, dark, edgy, horror

Gothic Clover Raccoon Skulls & Roses Pin

by Good Moods

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Attempted Murder – Two Black Ravens Dark Humor Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This eerie and humorous design features the phrase "Attempted Murder" with two black ravens, offering a dark twist on classic humor. Perfect for fans of gothic, spooky, and macabre designs, it’s a great pick for anyone who enjoys a little bit of mystery and ominous humor.

Tags: attempted murder, bird pun, black bird, creepy humor, gothic

Attempted Murder – Two Black Ravens Dark Humor Pin

by NomiCrafts

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

F-CAW-F Raven on Skull Gothic Art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A dark and atmospheric illustration featuring a raven perched atop a human skull. Bare, twisting tree branches frame the scene against a moody background. This gothic artwork captures a spooky and mysterious aesthetic perfect for fans of dark nature and macabre art.

Tags: bird, creepy, darkness, death, horror

F-CAW-F Raven on Skull Gothic Art Pin

by rombaganas

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Candle Market Cat Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween artwork featuring a black cat as the dominant focal point for candle merchant. Main text: CANDLE MARKET CAT. Secondary text: LIGHT FOR THE LONG NIGHT. Made for black cat lovers and Halloween fans, with a distinct tall vertical composition with the seated cat above a compact prop cluster.

Tags: black cat, black cat halloween, cat lov, dark aesthetic, halloween

Candle Market Cat Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween Pin

by Symbolic Studio

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Gothic Bat Holding Compass With Skull And Roses Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This striking design features a menacing bat gripping an antique compass amidst thorny vines and roses. A detailed skull anchors the composition, creating a perfect blend of gothic horror and nautical adventure aesthetics.

Tags: animal, compass, dark, demon, fantasy

Gothic Bat Holding Compass With Skull And Roses Pin

by gibah

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Gothic Elegance XI Bat Stamp Art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Ink sketch of a man in a suit and sunglasses alongside a bat skeleton on a teal postage stamp marked XI. Moody dark academia aesthetic for gothic fans.

Tags: bat skeleton, dark academia, dark fashion, fashion illustration, gothic aesthetic

Gothic Elegance XI Bat Stamp Art Pin

by Kanniax

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

The Last Witness – Gothic Black Cat Mystery Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: It saw everything. It will never tell. 🖤🐈‍⬛ A mysterious black cat holds a dark feather in its mouth, surrounded by dying candles, wilted crimson roses, ancient books, and a forgotten skull. Its piercing golden eyes seem to guard a secret no human was meant to uncover. Featuring “I SAW EVERYTHING,” this gothic design evokes silent witnesses, forgotten crimes, and the unsettling secrets hidden in the shadows. Perfect for lovers of dark mysteries, gothic cats, and vintage occult art.

Tags: animal, bird, black feather, cute, dream

The Last Witness – Gothic Black Cat Mystery Pin

by Nolinomeg

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Gothic Garden Moonlit Flytrap Dark Fantasy Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This gothic garden artwork invites you into a mysterious and eerie dark fantasy realm. Featuring an ethereal lady gazing at a moonlit scene with prominent venus flytraps and skeletal hands, this botanical horror illustration captures a truly unique aesthetic. Perfect for fans of macabre art and romantic goth vibes, this design embodies a beautiful and dark enchanting mystery.

Tags: botanical horror, dark fantasy, eerie moonlit flora, ethereal lady, fae

Gothic Garden Moonlit Flytrap Dark Fantasy Pin

by Anaksingkong

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Apothecary shelf with bottles and human skull Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This drawing focuses on an old wooden shelf packed with curiosities. The top shelf holds rows of different glass bottles and jars. Bundles of dried herbs hang from twine underneath. The middle shelf displays more jars, a stone mortar and pestle, and a set of antique books standing upright. A human skull sits on the bottom shelf next to a final collection of glass containers. Everything is captured in a detailed, engraved line art style. A thick vine of ivy winds around the structure, which is framed by a decorative border. It looks like a workspace for an alchemist or a classic herbalist.

Tags: alchemy, apothecary, botany, dark academia, gothic

Apothecary shelf with bottles and human skull Pin

by herocloth

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Moriarty Falls Sherlock Holmes Gothic Skull Mystery Art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This dark gothic metal-inspired design features the dramatic silhouette of Sherlock Holmes standing atop a cascading waterfall that morphs into a sinister skull. Emblazoned with the aggressive text "Moriarty Falls," it captures the legendary final confrontation at Reichenbach Falls against his archenemy. This gritty, atmospheric horror aesthetic is tailored for alternative bookworms, gothic fiction lovers, and fans of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's darker literary themes.

Tags: conan doyle, dark academia, detective, falls, gothic

Moriarty Falls Sherlock Holmes Gothic Skull Mystery Art Pin

by Fenay Designs

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Thriller Book Club Gothic Skull Logo Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Description : A spooky and gothic decorative badge designed for passionate horror, mystery, and thriller book club members who love suspense and dark aesthetics.

Tags: bloody handprint, book lover, creepy bookish, dark academia, fictional character

Thriller Book Club Gothic Skull Logo Pin

by Pixelated Parad

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Mystery Market Cat Retro Halloween Poster Halloween Pin

Description: Retro Halloween Poster Halloween artwork featuring a black cat as the dominant focal point for mystery shop. Main text: MYSTERY MARKET CAT. Secondary text: SOMETHING SPOOKY INSIDE. Made for black cat lovers and Halloween fans, with a distinct asymmetrical editorial layout with the cat on one side and typography on the other.

Tags: autumn market, black cat, black cat halloween, dark aesthetic, gothic cat

Mystery Market Cat Retro Halloween Poster Halloween Pin

by Symbolic Studio

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Dark Gothic Cat Skeleton Artwork with Edgy and Mysterious Vibes Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Explore this edgy design featuring a gothic-style cat skeleton, perfect for fans of dark art and unique, mysterious aesthetics.

Tags: alternative style, animal skeleton, cat skeleton, creepy cat, dark aesthetic
The Traitorss TV Show Gothic Mystery Hooded Cloak Castle Reality Game Art Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: The Traitorss TV Show Gothic Mystery Hooded Cloak Castle Reality Game Art

Tags: classic game show, pop culture, reality tv, reality tv fandom, the traitors
Gothic Red Wax Seal Emblem Dark Mystery Aesthetic Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Add an air of mystery and intrigue to your collection with this striking red wax seal design. Featuring an intricate symmetrical floral pattern, ornamental circular detailing, and a deep crimson palette, this emblem evokes secret correspondence, hidden alliances, and the atmosphere of a mysterious medieval society. Inspired by the suspenseful world of deception and secret identities, this design is perfect for fans of mystery games, gothic aesthetics, dark academia, vintage stationery, and secret society imagery. Its bold red-and-black contrast and decorative details make it a distinctive choice for apparel, stickers, and accessories. Whether you love psychological mysteries, vintage wax seals, or dark fantasy artwork, this elegant emblem

Tags: dark academia, fantasy emblem, gothic decor, gothic emblem, intrigue aesthetic

Gothic Red Wax Seal Emblem Dark Mystery Aesthetic Pin

by TheTreasureStash

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Potion Market Cat Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween artwork featuring a black cat as the dominant focal point for potion stall. Main text: POTION MARKET CAT. Secondary text: STRANGE GOODS & SPELLS. Made for black cat lovers and Halloween fans, with a distinct horizontal vintage sign with the cat centered and details at the outer edges.

Tags: autumn market, black cat, black cat halloween, cat lover, dark aesthetic

Potion Market Cat Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween Pin

by Symbolic Studio

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Cheshire Cat Blue Version Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Blue Cheshire Cat. One of two versions of dark Cheshire Cat from Alice in Creepyland collection made by DeneboArt

Tags: fairy tale character, alice in wonderland, cat, cat lover gift, creepy cute

Cheshire Cat Blue Version Pin

by DeneboArt

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

The Key Was Never Lost – Gothic Black Cat Mystery Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: The key was never lost. It was kept from you. 🖤🗝️ A mysterious black cat guards an ornate Victorian chest, wearing the only key around its neck. What lies inside—and why was it hidden in the first place? Deep burgundy velvet, antique gold details, crimson roses, and shadowy vintage ornaments give this design an atmosphere of forbidden knowledge and secrets best left untouched. Featuring “YOU WERE NEVER MEANT TO KNOW,” it’s perfect for gothic art lovers, mystery seekers, and fans of dark fantasy.

Tags: antique, antique key, burgundy velvet, crimson roses, forbidden secrets

The Key Was Never Lost – Gothic Black Cat Mystery Pin

by Nolinomeg

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Herbal Night Market Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween Pin

Description: Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween artwork featuring a black cat as the dominant focal point for herbal market. Main text: HERBAL NIGHT MARKET. Secondary text: GROWN, GATHERED & GUARDED. Made for black cat lovers and Halloween fans, with a distinct asymmetrical editorial layout with the cat on one side and typography on the other.

Tags: autumn market, black cat, cat lover, dark aesthetic, gothic cat

Herbal Night Market Gothic Folk Illustration Halloween Pin

by Symbolic Studio

$3.00 $3.25

for
--
:
--
:
--

Similar Designs

Cart Preview (0)

Adult Apparel

Kids Apparel

Home Goods