Current offer expires in
-- H
-- M
-- S
Up to 35% Off Sitewide
Shop Now

Unsettling Pins and Buttons

Filter

Safe Search on hides explicit content. Safe Search off shows all results, including explicit content.
Creepy Smile Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: well... hello there~

Tags: blue, creepy, green, happy, horror

Creepy Smile Pin

by GreyMerchOijen

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Disturbed Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Unsettling imagery that leans into dark, creepy and macabre themes. Blends grunge textures with surreal horror elements.

Tags: creepy, dark, distressed, eerie, gothic

Disturbed Pin

by Brooks Syndicate

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Unsettling Tom Face Meme Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Wear your unsettling-ness

Tags: unsettled tom meme, memes, face, joke, humor

Unsettling Tom Face Meme Pin

by tordo store

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Professionally Unsettling - Funny Home Haunter Halloween Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Professionally Unsettling - a haunt actor who is professionally unsettling. A vintage retro color illustration Halloween home haunter design, perfect as a Halloween gift for Halloween lovers, home haunters and spooky-season fans. Grab it for trick-or-treat night, costume parties, or everyday spooky-season style.

Tags: fall, funny halloween, halloween, halloween gift, halloween lover

Professionally Unsettling - Funny Home Haunter Halloween Pin

by Back2the90s

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Unsettling Clown Renders in Red Text Art Pin

Description: Unsettling Clown Renders in Red Text Art

Tags: acid bath reference, bunch of ballo, horror villain, red and white stripes, scary clown

Unsettling Clown Renders in Red Text Art Pin

by Michelle Larry's Store

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Unhinged Bunny with Evil Grinch Grin Meme Pin

Description: DESPICABLE bunny

Tags: bunny grinch smile, bunny mischievous smile, chaotic bunny illustration, chaotic energy meme, cursed cute meme

Unhinged Bunny with Evil Grinch Grin Meme Pin

by Veraphina

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Mother Schmucker Creepy Clown Portrait Design Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Button eyes, a too-wide grin, and a ruff collar framed by radiating linework give this grinning clown real unease in the "Mother Schmucker" design. Equal parts funny pun and genuinely unsettling art, it leans harder into horror than most novelty clown designs. A strong pick for horror fans, creepy-clown collectors, or anyone who wants their humor with a little bit of a shiver attached.

Tags: button eyes clown, clown fan gift, clown horror design, creepy carnival design, creepy clown design

Mother Schmucker Creepy Clown Portrait Design Pin

by Fisheyed Graphics

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Royal Rat Cyclist Unsettling the Common Folk Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A crowned royal rat rides an antique penny-farthing bicycle while wearing a flowing teal cape beneath the phrase “Off to Unsettle the Common Folk.” This whimsical design blends chaotic animal humor, vintage cycling style, and mischievous royal energy. A fun choice for rat lovers, rodent owners, bicycle enthusiasts, goblincore fans, oddity collectors, and anyone who enjoys eccentric humor.

Tags: bicycle humor, chaotic animal, chaotic animal humor, cycling, funny rodent gift

Royal Rat Cyclist Unsettling the Common Folk Pin

by Gift4U2025

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

"30% Wild" Unsettling Question (Printed in White) Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: The key question from the "Scary Animals in the Backyard" season of "30% Wild" - sure to start a conversation or two!

Tags: biodiversity, crow, environment, folklore, garden

"30% Wild" Unsettling Question (Printed in White) Pin

by 30% Wild Podcast

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

"30% Wild" Unsettling Question (Printed in Black) Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: The key question from the "Scary Animals in the Backyard" season of "30% Wild" - sure to start a conversation or two!

Tags: biodiversity, crow, environment, folklore, garden

"30% Wild" Unsettling Question (Printed in Black) Pin

by 30% Wild Podcast

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

The Unsettling Jester Ash Bentley Inspired Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Based on my original cross stitch design.

Tags: ash bentley, circus, horror, joker, spooky

The Unsettling Jester Ash Bentley Inspired Pin

by Sparkles Makes Studio

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Creepy Yellow Smile Face Spooky Halloween Meme Horror Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Unleash the nightmare with this creepy yellow smile face, perfect for fans of cursed memes and weirdcore aesthetic. This unsettling horror design is ideal for Halloween lovers and anyone who embraces the oddly terrifying side of internet culture.

Tags: creepy smile face, cursed image meme, disturbing art lover, halloween costume party, halloween horror fan

Creepy Yellow Smile Face Spooky Halloween Meme Horror Pin

by kog_ias

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

creepy vintage doll face Pin

Description: creepy vintage doll face

Tags: antique doll, big eye doll, cursed toy, doll close up, doll head

creepy vintage doll face Pin

by CosmicEquine Art

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Vomit Reflection Bathroom Horror Artwork Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This surreal artwork features a character vomiting into a bathroom sink, with the reflection in the mirror showing a distorted, eerie face. Set against a backdrop of yellow tiles and dark red walls with unsettling eyes peeking through cracks, it's a striking piece for fans of dark humor and gothic horror themes.

Tags: cartoon horror scene, character vomiting, creepy tiles, dark comedy design, dark humor illustration

Vomit Reflection Bathroom Horror Artwork Pin

by Hook Wool Std

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Are You Lost? Dreamcore in Cloud Blue Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Are you lost? You’ve strayed too far from the path. Don’t worry, I will help you.

Tags: core, dream, dreamer, glitch, glitch aesthetic

Are You Lost? Dreamcore in Cloud Blue Pin

by TheDoodlemancer

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Crouched Raider Beast Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A strange outsider-art character with heavy posture, aggressive silence, and an eerie grounded presence.

Tags: bizarre humanoid, crouched raider beast, dark fantasy creature, fantasy monster, mutant character

Crouched Raider Beast Pin

by Helgoolia

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Creepy Clown Toy in Store Aisle Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Dive into a chilling atmosphere with this striking design featuring a creepy clown toy nestled in a dimly lit store aisle. Perfect for fans of horror and the unsettling, this artwork captures the eerie charm of vintage toys, making it an ideal piece for any spooky decor enthusiast or as a unique gift for collectors.

Tags: clown collectibles, clown toy, collectible art, dark aesthetic, haunted toys

Creepy Clown Toy in Store Aisle Pin

by fuscolordgayl

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Donnie Darko, Frank The Rabbit Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Surreal, nightmarish rabbit mask illustration with dark, unsettling details and a horror-inspired mood.

Tags: creepy rabbit, dark surreal, eerie mask, gothic rabbit, horror portrait

Donnie Darko, Frank The Rabbit Pin

by Brooks Syndicate

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

buddy Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A unique horror crossover inspired by Buddy, blending elements from two cinematic works into one eerie and unsettling design. This artwork combines dark themes, creepy aesthetics, and the distinctive atmosphere of both films into a creative tribute to horror cinema.

Tags: buddy horror, creepy art, cult horror, dark art, dark cinema

buddy Pin

by pontoart

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Lost In The Backrooms Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A hazmat-suited figure wanders yellow wallpaper and buzzing fluorescents, lost deep in the Backrooms.

Tags: backrooms fan, backrooms horror, backrooms meme, creepypasta, fluorescent lights

Lost In The Backrooms Pin

by Bad Decisions

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Cheeese Gray Wolf Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A wolf with an unsettlingly wide grin says it like it means it. Creepy, funny, and impossible to look away from.

Tags: animal meme, canine art, cheese joke, dark comedy, dark humor

Cheeese Gray Wolf Pin

by Bask3tcas3_

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

wish i lacked critical thinking skills y'all seem so happy Pin

Description: wish i lacked critical thinking skills y'all seem so happy

Tags: chilling quote two, creepy quote two, eerie gift two idea, horror comedy gift two, horror lover gift two

wish i lacked critical thinking skills y'all seem so happy Pin

by PixelPunchart

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Dark Anime Horror – Monochrome Monster Face Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: I just thought it was cool.

Tags: anime fan art, black and white art, creature design, creepy anime, dark anime

Dark Anime Horror – Monochrome Monster Face Pin

by Ghost Kaida

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

wish i lacked critical thinking skills y'all seem so happy Pin

Description: wish i lacked critical thinking skills y'all seem so happy

Tags: chilling humor two, creepy vibe two, cryptic joke two, dark comedy gift three, dark humor gift three

wish i lacked critical thinking skills y'all seem so happy Pin

by PixelPunchart

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Surreal Horror Art with Creepy Doll Parts and Purple Monster Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This surreal horror illustration features a figure with a blank mask surrounded by creepy doll parts and a purple monstrous creature. The eerie scene combines dark fantasy and bizarre imagery, perfect for fans of unique, unsettling horror art.

Tags: abstract horror, bizarre drawing, creepy art, creepy doll parts, dark fantasy

Surreal Horror Art with Creepy Doll Parts and Purple Monster Pin

by BURRITO BREATH MEL

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Surreal Dark Creature Painting with Grotesque Claws Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This surreal dark creature painting features a grotesque figure with elongated claws set against a bloody, sunset-lit landscape. The eerie atmosphere and haunting brushstrokes make it perfect for lovers of horror and dark fantasy art.

Tags: abstract horror, black claws, creepy creature, dark art, dark fantasy art

Surreal Dark Creature Painting with Grotesque Claws Pin

by ARAP Neely Dirt

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Creepy Gothic Axolotl Dark Horror Sketch Character Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A haunting black-and-white axolotl character with hollow eyes, branchlike gills, and distressed sketch textures. An eerie choice for amphibian fans who enjoy gothic aesthetics, dark creatures, and spooky Halloween imagery.

Tags: aquatic salamander, black white, creepy amphibian, dark creature, distressed texture

Creepy Gothic Axolotl Dark Horror Sketch Character Pin

by cody game

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Let Me Out Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A creepy-cute dark creature surrounded by a chaotic "Let Me Out" chant — unsettling, quirky, and impossible to ignore.

Tags: alternative art, anxiety mood, dark creature, edgy design, existential meme

Let Me Out Pin

by Bask3tcas3_

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Visceral Horror Art Design Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This visceral horror art design captures the essence of dread and fear, featuring surreal elements in deep reds and dark undertones. Ideal for fans of the macabre and those looking to add a chilling touch to their decor or wardrobe, this piece transforms unsettling imagery into a unique artistic statement.

Tags: art for horror fans, artistic horror, blood art, creepy decor, dark fantasy

Visceral Horror Art Design Pin

by Dyas Veria

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Surreal Horror Scene with White-Haired Figure and Tentacled Eyes Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: This surreal horror design features a white-haired figure sitting on a ledge stained with red marks, facing a monstrous mass of tentacles and numerous watchful eyes. The dark, eerie background and unsettling composition make it perfect for fans of dark fantasy and horror art.

Tags: creepy creature, dark atmosphere, dark fantasy, eerie art, fantasy horror

Surreal Horror Scene with White-Haired Figure and Tentacled Eyes Pin

by fuscolordgayl

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Grotesque Void-Mouthed Monster Pin

Description: Disturbing humanoid monster with an oversized tooth-filled mouth, stringy tendrils spilling from the darkness within, and sinewy, flesh-toned limbs against a stark white background. A grotesque, surreal horror design perfect for fans of unsettling creature art.

Tags: creepy creature, distur, grotesque monster, horror, horror fan gift

Grotesque Void-Mouthed Monster Pin

by AlexBRD

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Chucky Wana Play Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: Playful yet unsettling, this design pairs a possessed toy vibe with the cheeky line “wanna play” for creepy humor. Simple horror style that leans into dark, spooky fun.

Tags: creepy toy, dark humor, doll collector, evil doll, halloween

Chucky Wana Play Pin

by SweetAdriaan

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Grim Grin – Distorted Dark Humor Design Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: “Grim Grin” captures the uneasy smile that appears when things are clearly not okay. A mix of humor, discomfort, and emotional contradiction hidden behind a familiar expression.

Tags: alternative culture, cynical mood, dark comedy, distorted expression, emotional masking

Grim Grin – Distorted Dark Humor Design Pin

by Hoku

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Obsession Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A dark female portrait beneath dramatic red “Obsession” lettering creates an unsettling horror aesthetic. A moody design for fans of psychological terror, sinister characters, and vintage horror poster styling

Tags: cinematic horror, creepy woman, dark art, eerie smile, gothic aesthetic

Obsession Pin

by LfgMike

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Masked Wraith Emergence Pin
Main Tag:  

Description: A haunting stylized illustration of a masked figure tearing through the frame with sharp lines, eerie tension, and unsettling purple energy.

Tags: chaotic entry, dark urban fantasy, distorted motion, eerie aura, expressive linework

Masked Wraith Emergence Pin

by Bernardo Illustrations

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Donnie Darko Pin

Description: Moody and surreal with psychological horror overtones and unsettling symbolism.

Tags: 80s retro, cinematic horror, cult classic, dark surrealism, eerie atmosphere

Donnie Darko Pin

by Taek Kabeh

$3.00 $3.25

for
-- days
--
:
--
:
--

Similar Designs

Cart Preview (0)

Adult Apparel

Kids Apparel

Home Goods