What material is this item made of?

Classic pin-back button covered with scratch and UV-resistant mylar. Printed in the U.S.A.

What USA ship methods are available?

UPS MI Domestic (6-8 Business Days) FedEx 2-Day (4-6 Business Days) Estimates include printing and processing time. More Shipping Info

What is the Return/Exchange policy?

We want you to love your order! If for any reason you don't, let us know and we’ll make things right. Learn More

Roll Fail Pins and Buttons for Sale

Main Tag

Description

Roll for Attraction Critical Fail

Tags: critical role, vox machina, call of cthulhu, cthulhu, d20

Roll for Attraction Critical Fail Pin

by Pixel Coated

$2.75 $2.00

DND D20 Critical Fail Dice Roll Bloody RPG Pin

Main Tag

Description

Dungeon Master, Fighter, Wizard, Paladin, Rogue, Ranger, Cleric, Barbarian or any other class don't miss this funny death defying design. Role-playing table top design features skull and die on a 1 crit failure roll.

Tags: d20, metal, pathfinder, dragon, dungeons and dragons

DND D20 Critical Fail Dice Roll Bloody RPG Pin

by NerdGamePlus

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Dungeon Master, Fighter, Wizard, Paladin, Rogue, Ranger, Cleric, Barbarian or any other class don't miss this funny death defying design. Role-playing table top design features skull and die on a 1 crit failure roll.

Tags: rpg, d20, fail, pathfinder, tabeltop

DND D20 Critical Fail Dice Roll Pin

by NerdGamePlus

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

When all words fail, eye rolling might be the best non-verbal expression 🙄

Tags: sunglasses, hot chick, chic, black and white design, eye rolling

Eye roll Pin

by yeknomster

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Critical fail guys~

Tags: critical hit, geek games, critical fail, dungeons and dragons, boardgames

Critical Fail Moments Pin

by pigboom

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Dungeon Master, Fighter, Wizard, Paladin, Rogue, Ranger, Cleric, Barbarian or any other class don't miss this funny death defying design. Role-playing table top design features skull and die on a 1 crit failure roll.

Tags: dragon, tabletop, gaming, dungeon, failure

DND D20 Crit Happens Fail Dice Roll Pin

by NerdGamePlus

$2.75 $2.00

This is How I Roll (Crit Fail) - D20 Series Pin

Main Tag

Description

"This is How I Roll (Crit Fail)", fun saying. Part of the D20 series

Tags: crit, d20, dice, dnd, dungeon master

This is How I Roll (Crit Fail) - D20 Series Pin

by SilverFoxx Designs

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

I hope Frankie approves

Tags: critical roll, critical fail, crit happens, gm, frankie say relax

GM SAY CRIT [black] Pin

by DCLawrenceUK

$2.75 $2.00

My critical fail made me do it - blue Pin

Main Tag

Description

You know, sometimes the dice god give and take... And here, he takes you luck away.

Tags: colorful design, critical failures, critical role, critical roll, d20

My critical fail made me do it - blue Pin

by AtelierRillian

$2.75 $2.00

My critical fail made me do it - violet dice Pin

Main Tag

Description

You know, sometimes the dice god give and take... And here, he takes you luck away.

Tags: colorful design, critical, critical failures, critical role, critical roll

My critical fail made me do it - violet dice Pin

by AtelierRillian

$2.75 $2.00

My critical fail made me do it - orange Pin

Main Tag

Description

You know, sometimes the dice god give and take... And here, he takes you luck away.

Tags: colorful design, critical, critical failures, critical role, critical roll

My critical fail made me do it - orange Pin

by AtelierRillian

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

DnD Critical Fail Dice.

Tags: natural 1, roleplay game, critical role, role playing game, die

Critical Fail Pin

by OctoberArts

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

I hope Frankie approves

Tags: critical fail, dnd, critical roll, frankie say relax mashup, dungeons and dragons

DM SAY CRIT [black] Pin

by DCLawrenceUK

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Tags: dungeons and dragons, criticalhit, critical roll, critical fail, criticalrole

Nice Crits! Pin

by Wykd_Life

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Tags: dungeons and dragons, barbarians, barbarian, pathfinder, criticalhit

Barbarians! Pin

by Wykd_Life

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Sometimes it happens.. everything is going great.. and then.. BAM! Crit Fail! Why??

Tags: batman, crit, critical fail, d20, dice

Why So Critical? Pin

by Fighter Guy Studios

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Tags: dungeons and dragons, criticalhit, critical roll, critical fail, criticalrole

All Natural Pin

by Wykd_Life

$2.75 $2.00

You Can Certainly Try - cute ombre design Pin

Main Tag

Description

Oh, you want to seduce the dragon? You can certainly try...

Tags: game master gift tabletop rpg gm dnd, bard dragon elf barbarian, goblin druid rogue cleric, natural one critical hit critical fail, d20 d 20 dice

You Can Certainly Try - cute ombre design Pin

by AmandaPandaBrand

$2.75 $2.00

You Can Certainly Try - Cyan/Light Blue Dragon Pin

Main Tag

Description

Oh, you want to seduce the dragon? You can certainly try...

Tags: roll for initiative, matt mercer laura bailey, cute girly dnd, dm dungeon master, natural one critical hit critical fail

You Can Certainly Try - Cyan/Light Blue Dragon Pin

by AmandaPandaBrand

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Oh, you want to seduce the dragon? You can certainly try...

Tags: you can certainly try dungeons, dungeons and dragons, d20 d 20 dice, christmas birthday, dm dungeon master

You Can Certainly Try - Pink Dragon Pin

by AmandaPandaBrand

$2.75 $2.00

Critical Roll Fail Heartbeat Dungeons and Dragons Dice Deathsave Pin

Main Tag

Description

Roll with the unexpected in our tee – a casual nod to the thrill of gaming. Watch the heartbeat line pause at 1, capturing the spontaneous charm of life's dice rolls. Grab yours, embrace the fun, and let the good times roll! 🎲❤️ #DiceyHeartbeat #CasualGaming"

Tags: d20, deathsave, dice, dnd, dungeon master

Critical Roll Fail Heartbeat Dungeons and Dragons Dice Deathsave Pin

by Goforth Gaming

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Oh, you want to seduce the dragon? You can certainly try...

Tags: you can certainly try dungeons, dm dungeon master, natural one critical hit critical fail, game master gift tabletop rpg gm dnd, dm gift

You Can Certainly Try - Blue Dragon Pin

by AmandaPandaBrand

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

We have all been there, the enemy boss has only a few hp left, it all comes down to one dice roll, you roll to hit the boss into oblivion. And it's a critical failure or a Natural one. So for all those times when the dice gods haven't been on your side, misadventure awaits.

Tags: roleplaying games critical fail, d and d, roleplaying games, rollplaying games, d20 dice

Natural One - Misfortune awaits Pin

by BRU Design

$2.75 $2.00

You Can Certainly Try - Purple Dragon Pin

Main Tag

Description

Oh, you want to seduce the dragon? You can certainly try...

Tags: cute girly dnd, matt mercer laura bailey, d20 d 20 dice, dm gift, dungeons and dragons

You Can Certainly Try - Purple Dragon Pin

by AmandaPandaBrand

$2.75 $2.00

2021 Is This Where The Side Quest Ends? Pin

Main Tag

Description

2021 was NOT what we signed up for. If you're ready to get back to the prime storyline, this is the shirt for you!

Tags: critical fail, critical hit, d20, d and d, dice game

2021 Is This Where The Side Quest Ends? Pin

by designedbygeeks

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

2021 was NOT what we signed up for and 2022 isn't looking to start much better. If you're ready to get back to the prime storyline, this is the shirt for you!

Tags: roleplay, dice jail, dungeons and dragons, dnd, d and d

2022 When Does This Side Quest End? Pin

by designedbygeeks

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Natural one DnD Dice.

Tags: criticalrole, critical fail, critical hit, critical roll, dm

natural one Pin

by OctoberArts

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

natural 1 dnd dice.

Tags: critical roll, roleplayer, d and d, criticalrole, dice

Natural 1 Pin

by OctoberArts

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Oh, you want to seduce the dragon? You can certainly try...

Tags: matt mercer laura bailey, bard dragon elf barbarian, goblin druid rogue cleric, d20 d 20 dice, game master gift tabletop rpg gm dnd

You Can Certainly Try - Red Pin

by AmandaPandaBrand

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Sometimes the dice just fall in your favour!

Tags: dice game, dice, dungeon master, acid, dungeons and dragons game

Crit Happens (20) [Acid] Pin

by DCLawrenceUK

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

RPG - Im Doing Just Fine

Tags: dungeon master, game, failure, fail, dungeons and dragons

RPG - Im Doing Just Fine Pin

by The Inked Smith

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Old School Gamer fun... Roll a 1, see what is gonna kick you in the face with your critical fail.

Tags: roll a 1, crit fail, old school gamer, traditional tattoo art, dungeons and dragons

Mommy's Little Critical Fail Pin

by SQ Geekwear

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

This is how I roll - with skulls… :-)

Tags: spooky, fail, how to, skulls, silly

This Is How I Roll - Skulls Pin

by ORENOB

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Another epic fail!

Tags: role play, dungeon master, critical miss, tabletop, gaming

Crit Happens! Pin

by Hiraeth Tees

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

This is how I roll - with skulls… :-)

Tags: skull, cute, this is how i roll, skulz, spooky

This is how I roll - skulls Pin

by ORENOB

$2.75 $2.00

Main Tag

Description

Heads Will Roll - with a pile of skulls … :-)

Tags: fail, row, this is how i roll, fall, roll

Heads Will Roll - skulls Pin

by ORENOB

$2.75 $2.00

Sign Up

Cart Preview (0)

Your Cart is empty...

Shop Designs

Holidays & Occasions

Artist Collections

Adult Apparel

Kids Apparel

Kids T-Shirts

Kids Hoodie

Accessories

Home Goods

Shop Designs

Apparel

Accessories

Home Goods

Popular Products

Browse All Topics

Support

Adult Apparel

T-Shirts

Tank Tops

Hoodies

Crewneck Sweatshirts

Long Sleeve T-Shirts

Baseball T-Shirts

Kids Apparel

Kids T-Shirts

Kids Hoodie

Home Goods

Wall Art

Mugs

Pillows

Tapestries

Pins

Cases & Stickers

Phone Cases

Stickers

Magnets

Merchandise

Top Tags

im in my prime

thug life

dickey betts

mothers day

bluey

never not funny

mom

deadpool

baby billy

anime

Roll Fail Pins and Buttons

Product Sort + Filter

Adult Apparel

T-Shirts

Tank Tops

Hoodies

Crewneck Sweatshirts

Long Sleeve T-Shirts

Baseball T-Shirts

Merch

Kids Apparel

Kids T-Shirts

Kids Hoodie

Merch

Home Goods

Wall Art

Mugs

Pillows

Tapestries

Pins

Merch

Cases & Stickers

Phone Cases

Stickers

Magnets

Merch

Pin FAQ

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Support